Max Forrester Eastman

(January 4, 1883 – March 25, 1969)

Max Forrester Eastman was an influential American socialist in early 20th-century that had a change of heart after witnessing, first hand, the failure of the grand experiment. He edited The Masses and The Liberator magazines, championed women’s rights, and initially cheered on the Bolshevik Revolution, believing socialism would unlock greater freedom for everyone.

He visited the Soviet Union in the 1920s and saw reality up close: brutal power struggles between Trotsky and Stalin, totalitarianism, friends targeted and assassinated, the crushing of the very liberties he cared about most. The failure of socialism to deliver on its promises hit him particularly hard. He returned to America convinced that Marxism is fundamentally flawed and centralized planning could not coexist with human flourishing.

Max changed his tune, shaped by the hardships of the Great Depression and the ideas of economists like Friedrich Hayek and Ludwig von Mises. He fully embraced free-market capitalism as the only system that supports individual liberty, genuine progress, and human dignity.

He became a vocal anti-communist, writing regularly for Reader’s Digest and The Freeman. Max summed up his journey in his seminal book Reflections on the Failure of Socialism where many of the quotes on this site can be found.

~ Lucio Saverio Eastman

Max Eastman Quotes

socialist hypothesis
Socialism |  Capitalism |  Communism |  Economics

Socialist Hypothesis

“If the socialist hypothesis were valid in general, some tiny shred of the benefits promised by it would have appeared when the Russian capitalists were expropriated and production taken over by the state…” ~Max Eastman
Science Is...
Religion |  Philosophy |  Science

Science is…

Science is: “patience in investigation and clarity in calculation; singleness of purpose; the power to suspend judgement, to remain, if need be, for a lifetime in doubt…” ~Max Eastman
Sickening Discipline
Socialism |  Communism |  Philosophy

Sickening Discipline

“Those consecrating themselves to communism must not only cast out truth, mercy, justice, and personal honor, but undergo a sickening discipline in lies, cruelty, crime and self abasement.” ~Max Eastman

“Max Eastman spent the first half of his life trying to fit himself into larger frameworks: Christianity (provided, somewhat unorthodoxly, by his mother); feminism (promoted even more unconventionally by his sister); and then socialism (advocated by his uncompromising first wife). When each ideology appeared to fit Max into prescribed patterns of institutional behavior— of the church, the party, or any other organization—he balked.

Max spent the second half of his life looking for an ideological home while trying to defend himself against those who seemed to know exactly what he was thinking and where he belonged.” 

From Max Eastman: A Life
by Christoph Irmscher

Claude McKay with Max in 1923, both of whom abandoned their socialist beliefs and became highly critical of Marxism.